Fatal Beating in Brooklyn for Wife's Lover

A 34 year old man was beaten to death outside his own factory.

Crime: Murder

Occurred: Sunday, 30 October 2011

Where: 19 Industry Park Drive, Brooklyn

Sentenced: 5 April 2013

Convicted: Mark Budimir

Victim: Dino Moresco

What happened?
Jana, Mark's wife, ran a nursery in Footscray called "Garden Door".  She purchased garden ornaments from Dino, who ran a manufacturing business in Brooklyn.  Jana began a sexual affair with him the day after he, her, and Mark had gone out together to celebrate her birthday in August 2011.  At this stage, Mark was unaware of the relationship between his wife and her garden ornament supplier.

In September 2011, after months of Jana threatening to leave the marriage, she left for a weekend away with Dino, while Mark stayed at home with the kids. Following the weekend, Mark learned from a friend that she had attended a nightclub with Dino. He also suspected Dino had joined her in Sydney the following night. Upon her return, Mark discovered racy text messages on her phone, and he realised that Dino and Jana were more than business associates.

A few days later, Mark drove over to Dino's factory in Brooklyn and threatened that if Dino did not leave Jana alone, Mark would put him on the "front page of the newspapers".


From left to right: Mark, Jana and Dino in happier times (source).

Soon afterwards, Jana told Mark to leave the matrimonial home because the marriage was over. In response, Mark slapped Jana across the face several times and then locked her in the bedroom.  Police were called, and Jana later applied for an intervention order. Mark was also convicted for false imprisonment and assault in relation to the bedroom incident, for which he received a suspended sentence.

On Sunday, 30 October, Mark drove around to his wife's house to find her and Dino loading some of Mark's belongings into a truck. Outraged, he then drove to Dino's factory and was spotted wearing gloves and running about suspiciously to avoid detection. A witness phoned Dino to alert him that someone behaving oddly was at the factory.

Some time later, Dino arrived at his factory to investigate. Mark caught him by the jumper and wrestled with him on the ground. Mark was able to struggle free and stood up, picking Dino up in the air and then throwing him down on the ground, where he landed on his head. Blood came out of his mouth. Mark then stood on Dino's chest several times, before loading him into his own truck and driving out to an abandoned industrial site.

He fetched some petrol from his parent's house nearby and returned, shoving Dino head first into a wheelie bin and setting it on fire.

While Dino's corpse burned, Mark drove off to buy a kebab and did a quick drive by on the fire before zooming off to New South Wales. He rang his wife, abusing her for her disloyalty before telling her that he had gotten rid of Dino so that Jana could return to him.  He also reportedly rang police and told them that he would only turn himself in after taking a holiday to Northern Australia (where and Jana had once enjoyed a nice vacation). Police were able to trace his location from his mobile phone, and arrested him in Broken Hill.

Victim's background

Dino's cousin and mother attended Court (source).

Dino was 34 when he was killed.  He reportedly ran his manufacturing business very successfully and was planning to soon retire.

Jana said in her victim impact statement, "The crime ended my physical relationship with Dino, but the emotional relationship continues. I cannot stop loving Dino."

His parents visit his grave every day.

Convicted's background
Mark was almost 41 at the time of the murder.  He met Jana at age 19, his first serious girlfriend, and they were married in their early twenties.   They had four children, who are now aged from 8 to 15.

The judge commented that Mark had lived a "largely blameless and in many respects admirable life" as a husband, father and small business owner.

Mark had former convictions of burglary, criminal damage and theft dating back to 1996 (occurring in the context of recovering a debt), as well as the conviction noted above for false imprisonment and intentionally causing injury to Jana when she asked him to leave in September 2011.

Mark also suffers from hepatitis C.

Outcome of trial: Mark pleaded not guilty to murder, but a jury of his peers found otherwise.  The judge commented on Mark's "vehement attack" pursued in cross-examination against Jana during the trial, suggesting that Mark blamed Jana as the "cause of the evil" in relation to the murder.

Sentence: 16 years before eligible for parole (18 years max), with over a year and a half already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Mark escorted out of the Court following sentencing (source).

Cranbourne Drug Dealer Dies by Shovel and Nylon Strap

A 48 year old man was fatally beaten and strangled in his home.

Crime: Manslaughter

Occurred:  Saturday, 20 August 2011

Where: 15 Golden Wattle Court, Cranbourne

Sentenced:  27 March 2013

Convicted:  Glenn Hollow

Victim:  Laurence Grey

What happened?
In mid-August 2011, Glenn drove down from Sydney to visit his sister in St Kilda.  He met up with a friend, Anthony Lucas, and the two men spent a few days living in their cars, tight for cash.  On Saturday, Glenn texted several people, asking for $50.  Later that day, both men drove down to Laurence's house in Cranbourne.  Laurence shared some heroin with Anthony and then showed his guests a couple of cars that he was restoring.

At some point during the visit, Laurence was struck over the head with a post-hole shovel and strangled with a black nylon strap.  Both Glenn and Anthony participated in the attack.  They stole cash and cannabis and fled back to Melbourne.

Laurence's body was discovered two days later on his patio.

Laurence's house at 15 Golden Wattle Court, Cranbourne (source).

Victim's background
Laurence was 48 years old at the time of his death.  He was described by police as a low level drug dealer, selling approximately half a pound of cannabis a week for the last 10 years.  Laurence's best friend told the media that Laurence was very excited about a new job he was going to apply for: "He was cleaning himself up, he was getting himself together, and then this happened".  After his body was discovered, police publicly appealed to his former drug customers, who may have visited the premises around the time of Laurence's death, to come forward and share any relevant information with authorities.

Laurence left behind his 80 year old mother, a sister, and a brother, who he had not spoken to for two years. Laurence lived alone with two dogs.

Laurence Grey (source).

Convicted's background
Glenn was approximately 34 years old at the time of the killing.  Born and raised in Ararat, he was the middle child of three.  He was sexually abused as a child.  His older brother died in a car accident at age 27. He left school in Year 10 and joined the army aged 15, participating in tours to Somalia, Cambodia and Bougainville.

At age 18, after he was dishonorably discharged for assaulting an officer, Glenn moved back to Ararat to live with his parents and work at his mum's cafe. Not long after, he was arrested for car theft and possession of a firearm, which is likely to have been related to an incident where he stole his mother's car and threatened to commit suicide.

He became a truckie and at age 22 moved out of home to live with his girlfriend, and later wife, Kelly Martin, and they later had three kids, today aged 15, 12 and 10.

At 23, Glenn received a suspended sentence and a community service order for stealing $140,000 from his employers.  After serving out the order, he moved his family to Queensland and worked as an estimator. After being overlooked for a promotion he stole $100,000 from his boss.  He was charged and released on bail but fled to Melbourne with his family, where he returned to truck driving and amphetamine use.  After a truck roll incident in 2006, he required a spinal fusion and suffered ongoing back pain.

At 31, Glenn's marriage was failing.  Around this time he entered his wife's caravan with an offensive weapon and was sentenced to 14 months in prison (5 months before eligible for parole).  After serving 6 months, he was released and extradited to Brisbane where he was sentenced to 4 years and 6 months imprisonment. He was released in August 2010 after serving 2 years, and then violated his parole conditions in order to relocate to Victoria.

Glenn also has a history of abusing painkillers and amphetamines and also has been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder.

Glenn was a truck driver (source).

Outcome of trial: Glenn initially pleaded not guilty but during the trial changed his mind.  The trial was discontinued.  The judge estimated that this saved two weeks of the Court's time.

Sentence: 7 years and 3 months before eligible for parole (10 years max), with over a year and a half already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Geelong Man Kicked to Death for Defecating on Floor

A 55 year old alcoholic was bashed to death in a Geelong hotel.

Crime:  Murder / manslaughter

Occurred:  Sunday, 2 October 2011

Where:  Sir Charles Hotham Hotel, Geelong

Convicted #1:  Bradley James Walters (murder)

Sentenced:  7 December 2012

Convicted #2: Brett Ross Drummond (manslaughter)
Sentenced: 13 March 2013

Victim: Edwin Singer

What happened?

Bradley, Brett and Edwin were residents at the Sir Charles Hotham Hotel in Geelong.  Bradley and Edwin were unemployed alcoholics.  Brett worked in a local factory and also drank heavily.

Bradley and Brett were friends with the hotel cleaner, who had complained for some time about Edwin's habit of defecating in public areas of the hotel.  Over a number of incidents she discovered faeces on the carpet and sheets in his room, in the foyer, out on the street and in the bathroom.  Hotel residents, including Bradley and Brett, were growing increasingly upset at this behaviour.

On the Saturday before his death, a large smear of faeces appeared on the hallway carpet outside the bathroom door.  A trail of footsteps led back to Edwin's room.

Bradley confronted Edwin and told him he had a day to clean up the mess, but Edwin denied responsibility.

On Sunday, Bradley drank five to six litres of cask wine before intercepting Edwin on his way to the bathroom.  Bradley punched Edwin until he was on the floor and then kicked him repeatedly with his steel capped boots.

Bradley returned to his drinking while Edwin crawled back to his bedroom.  At various points in the evening Bradley returned to continue his assault on Edwin, at one stage accompanied by Brett, who also joined in the beating and who had consumed at least ten beers.

Later in the evening, the men dragged Edwin out to the fire escape.  He was either dead at the time or died soon after while he was at this location.  The men later dumped Edwin's corpse in a driveway neighbouring the hotel.

Victims' background

Edwin Singer (source)

Edwin, who was 55 years old at the time of his death and suffering from emphysema, died from blunt force trauma and sustained a number of injuries including a fractured nose, sternum and 27 rib fractures.  He is survived by a sister, a daughter and a step daughter.  His daughter, who was already suffering depression before his death, has deteriorated in mental condition since he was killed and now requires significant care from her step sister.  He was 55 years old when he died.  A year before his death he had participated in a newspaper interview and told journalists that he was a former social worker and had worked at Deakin University, but it is not clear whether this was true.

Convicted #1's background

Bradley was 45 years old at the time of the attack.  Born in Geelong, the middle child of five children and the son of a truck driver and a canteen worker, he did not enjoy a good relationship with his father and began drinking on a daily basis by the age of 17.  He left school at the end of Year 11.  At 22 he left home and fell in and out of employment, ending up mostly working in fruit picking, a lifestyle that enabled him to continue to drink heavily.

By the age of 27 Bradley had two children to another alcoholic, Pauline.  The couple were unable to look after their children and when the kids were aged 5 and 7 they were placed into the welfare system and Bradley has not seen them for over 12 years.

The Sir Charles Hotham Hotel (source)

A psychologist who interviewed Bradley for his trial observed that Bradley 'seems to be of the view that alcohol is the only thing that can give his life even the most fleeting sense of meaning'.

Convicted #2's background
Brett was approximately 44 years old at the time of the murder.  Born in Geelong, he was the middle child among six siblings.  His mother and father were both alcoholics and Brett suffered sexual abuse at the hands of two uncles.  By the time he was six years old, all of the children in the family had been placed into alternative care.  Brett spent the rest of his childhood in and out of boys' homes.  He began drinking at 14.  He left school after Year 10 and worked as a factory hand and woodcutter.  A psychologist described that at the time of sentencing Brett was "bordering on frank alcoholism".

Brett has a low IQ.  He has a prior criminal history that includes three assaults, dishonesty and driving offences, and a period of imprisonment.  At the time of the manslaughter he was on a suspended sentence for driving offences.

Outcome of trial

#1:  Bradley confessed what he did to police and was willing to plead guilty to manslaughter, but due to a number of factors (including that he continued to return to Edwin for more beatings throughout the night of the murder, indicating deliberateness), the prosecution pursued a murder charge and the matter proceeded to trial, where Bradley was found guilty by a jury of his peers.

#2:  Similarly, the prosecution pursued a charge of murder against Brett but changed its mind shortly before the sentence was handed down.  Brett pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter, and no trial was necessary.

Sentence

Bradley was sentenced to 17 years imprisonment before eligible before parole, 20 years maximum.  The judge recognised that Bradley had already served well over a year of his sentence whilst on remand.

You can read more about the crime here and here and the judgement for Bradley here and for Brett here.

The crime scene near where the body was found (source)