Take note

The content of this blog is based on publicly available information and is intended to convey a short summary of facts surrounding each Victorian murder and the sentence imposed. It is not pushing an agenda for harsher/more lenient sentencing practices in Victoria.
Showing posts with label manslaughter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manslaughter. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Grumpy Old Man Slays Housemate in Clayton

A convicted murderer stabbed his housemate to death over a garden bed dispute.

Crime: Manslaughter

Occurred: Thursday, 20 October 2011

Where: 13 Thompson Street, Clayton

Sentenced: 9 April 2013 

Convicted:  Periklis Papadopoulos

Victim:  Andonios Mirtsopoulos

What happened?
Periklis lived in Clayton with Andonios and another gentleman named George, in what the Judge described as a 'rooming house, of some sort, for elderly Greek men'.  Unfortunately, Periklis and Andonios did not get along.  Two weeks prior to his death, Andonios dug out a garden bed for a vegie patch.  On the night before the killing, Periklis planted his own vegetables in the garden bed.  The next day, upon discovering his vegetable patch had been stolen, Andonios loudly complained to George.  Periklis emerged from the house, holding a knife and a pear, and an argument then ensued.  George watched as the two men yelled at each other.  Andonios began pulling out the tomato plants. Periklis pushed Andonios into the fence. The pair exchanged fisticuffs until George broke them up.  Not content to leave it there, Periklis ran back towards Andonios, who also moved towards Periklis.  Periklis plunged the knife into Andonios' chest, killing him at the scene. Periklis said, "oh no what have I done, I'm going to go to jail for this bastard".  He ran inside, changed his clothes and fled out onto the driveway.
13 Thompson Street, Clayton, where the manslaughter occurred.
Victim's background
Andonios was 72 years old when he was killed.  He was estranged from his wife and children, which the Judge noted made it all the more sadder that his death cemented no prospect of reconciliation with his family.  Shortly before his death his daughter had gotten back in contact with him.

Convicted's background
Periklis grew up in a poor farming family in a Greek village.  His family were unable to afford his education and he left school at 16 and became a tradesman painter. He migrated to Australia in 1969, met his wife and moved back to Greece in 1978 with her in tow.  After having a son and daughter, the marriage was understood to have come to an end, but the couple continued living under one roof due to religious and social pressures.

In 1992, Periklis was convicted in Greece for the voluntary homicide of his cousin, a charge equivalent to murder under Victorian law. That incident occurred after a hunting trip, when the cousins stopped in at a tavern for a drink.  Periklis and his cousin were involved in an argument.  Periklis fetched his gun from the boot of his car and shot his cousin dead.

After being convicted and serving a total of 16 years, he was released from prison in 2008. He left his wife and children in Greece and migrated back to Australia and worked as a painter, living at the premises in Clayton.  For the six months leading up to the manslaughter, Periklis and Andonios had bickered over petty issues and there was one other occasion when their housemate George had to break them up.  Periklis was 65 years old at the time of the stabbing.
Periklis planted four or five tomato and pepper plants
in the controversial garden bed (source).

Outcome of trial 
There was no trial because Periklis pleaded guilty.

Sentence 
Periklis was sentenced to a maximum of 11 years and six months with a minimum 9 years before eligible for parole.  Almost a year and a half of the sentence was served while on remand.

In sentencing, the Judge commented that both the victim and the convicted were 'grumpy old men' and that Periklis had been 'provocative' in planting his vegetables in Andonios' garden bed.  The Judge took into account the prior conviction in Greece and stated that specific and general deterrence were significant factors taken into consideration in the sentence, given that Periklis had been released from prison in 2008 and three years later had killed again and the killing had occurred over such a 'petty issue'.  The Judge commented on Periklis' limited remorse, stating that any remorse Periklis indicated was concerned mainly with the punishment befalling him rather than his actions.  The Judge further stated that the sentence reflected a need to protect the public.  Had the Periklis not pleaded guilty, he would have been sentenced to 13 years with a minimum of 10 years and six months before eligible for parole.

This case was unsuccessfully appealed by Periklis in 2014.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here and here.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Cranbourne Drug Dealer Dies by Shovel and Nylon Strap

A 48 year old man was fatally beaten and strangled in his home.
Crime: Manslaughter

Occurred:  Saturday, 20 August 2011

Where: 15 Golden Wattle Court, Cranbourne

Sentenced:  27 March 2013

Convicted:  Glenn Hollow

Victim:  Laurence Grey

What happened?
In mid-August 2011, Glenn drove down from Sydney to visit his sister in St Kilda.  He met up with a friend, Anthony Lucas, and the two men spent a few days living in their cars, tight for cash.  On Saturday, Glenn texted several people, asking for $50.  Later that day, both men drove down to Laurence's house in Cranbourne.  Laurence shared some heroin with Anthony and then showed his guests a couple of cars that he was restoring.

At some point during the visit, Laurence was struck over the head with a post-hole shovel and strangled with a black nylon strap.  Both Glenn and Anthony participated in the attack.  They stole cash and cannabis and fled back to Melbourne.

Laurence's body was discovered two days later on his patio.
Laurence's house at 15 Golden Wattle Court, Cranbourne (source).

Victim's background
Laurence was 48 years old at the time of his death.  He was described by police as a low level drug dealer, selling approximately half a pound of cannabis a week for the last 10 years.  Laurence's best friend told the media that Laurence was very excited about a new job he was going to apply for: "He was cleaning himself up, he was getting himself together, and then this happened".  After his body was discovered, police publicly appealed to his former drug customers, who may have visited the premises around the time of Laurence's death, to come forward and share any relevant information with authorities.

Laurence left behind his 80 year old mother, a sister, and a brother, who he had not spoken to for two years. Laurence lived alone with two dogs.
Laurence Grey (source).

Convicted's background
Glenn was approximately 34 years old at the time of the killing.  Born and raised in Ararat, he was the middle child of three.  He was sexually abused as a child.  His older brother died in a car accident at age 27. He left school in Year 10 and joined the army aged 15, participating in tours to Somalia, Cambodia and Bougainville.

At age 18, after he was dishonorably discharged for assaulting an officer, Glenn moved back to Ararat to live with his parents and work at his mum's cafe. Not long after, he was arrested for car theft and possession of a firearm, which is likely to have been related to an incident where he stole his mother's car and threatened to commit suicide.

He became a truckie and at age 22 moved out of home to live with his girlfriend, and later wife, Kelly Martin, and they later had three kids, today aged 15, 12 and 10.

At 23, Glenn received a suspended sentence and a community service order for stealing $140,000 from his employers.  After serving out the order, he moved his family to Queensland and worked as an estimator. After being overlooked for a promotion he stole $100,000 from his boss.  He was charged and released on bail but fled to Melbourne with his family, where he returned to truck driving and amphetamine use.  After a truck roll incident in 2006, he required a spinal fusion and suffered ongoing back pain.

At 31, Glenn's marriage was failing.  Around this time he entered his wife's caravan with an offensive weapon and was sentenced to 14 months in prison (5 months before eligible for parole).  After serving 6 months, he was released and extradited to Brisbane where he was sentenced to 4 years and 6 months imprisonment. He was released in August 2010 after serving 2 years, and then violated his parole conditions in order to relocate to Victoria.

Glenn also has a history of abusing painkillers and amphetamines and also has been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder.

Glenn was a truck driver (source).

Outcome of trial: Glenn initially pleaded not guilty but during the trial changed his mind.  The trial was discontinued.  The judge estimated that this saved two weeks of the Court's time.

Sentence: 7 years and 3 months before eligible for parole (10 years max), with over a year and a half already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Baby Died in Glenroy Driveway

A ten month old baby died inside a closed car on a warm day.
Crime: Manslaughter

Occurred:  5 November 2011

Where: Glenroy

Sentenced: 12 February 2013

Convicted: Michelle Nguyen 

Victim:  Thy Tran

What happened?
At approximately 11:30am on a warm spring Saturday, 20 year old Michelle Nguyen took her two daughters, Thao and Thy, for a drive around the neighbourhood so that they would fall asleep.  When Michelle arrived back at her friend's house, Thao awoke and Michelle took her inside, leaving Thy inside the car to sleep.

A little later, Michelle checked on her baby, made sure she was still asleep, and then shut the car door without leaving the window down.  The temperature outside was 28 degrees celsius.  During the next few hours, the temperature inside the car reached almost 49 degrees. Meanwhile, inside the house, Michelle fell asleep watching tv.

At 2pm, Michelle awoke and checked on her baby to make the horrific discovery that her child was dead.  Michelle moved the baby inside, rang emergency services and tried to resuscitate her with no success.  When paramedics arrived, Michelle initially stated that her child had died inside the house, but this story did not add up; even deceased, Thy's temperature had a reading of over 41 degrees celsius.  Later she admitted to police that the death had occurred inside the car. Thy died from hyperthermia.

Victim's background
Thy Tran was a 10 month old baby when she died.  Her father was in prison at the time of her death.

Convicted's background
Michelle's mother was 14 when she had Michelle in Australia.  Both of Michelle's parents were heroin users and split up when Michelle was 11.  She has one half-sister.  She attended Marion College in Sunshine West until Year 10 and later began a hairdressing course at Vic Uni.  Around this time, she entered into a relationship with a heroin trafficker 12 years her senior.  She had her first child at 17 by accident and had her second daughter, Thy, when she was 19.  Shortly after Thy's birth, Michelle's partner was imprisoned for drug related offences.

At the age of 16, Michelle became a regular user of ice and methamphetamine and developed a heroin addiction.  While pregnant she moved onto alternative therapies and participated in a specialist program at Sunshine West for drug dependent expectant mothers.  After her children were born she resumed using heroin.

At the time of Thy's death, Michelle was not enjoying a good relationship with her mother and was staying at a friend's house who provided a mattress to accommodate Michelle and her two daughters.  In the time leading up to her baby's death, Michelle had been warned by several individuals to be careful about leaving her in the car alone.

Shortly after her baby's death, Michelle's partner was released from prison, and was allegedly physically abusive towards Michelle and destroyed her possessions until she broke off contact with him.

Michelle had no prior convictions when sentenced.
Michelle Nguyen in Court (source).


Outcome of trial: Michelle pleaded guilty so a trial was unnecessary.

Sentence: Nine months minimum before eligible for parole, four years maximum.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Tuesday, August 23, 2011

King Hit in Yarraville

Crime: Manslaughter
Occurred: 14 July 2009
Sentenced: 16 August 2011
Where:  Outside the Blarney Stone Irish Pub in Yarraville (35 Anderson Street)
Convicted: 
Jacob Polutele
Victim: Cain Aguiar


What happened?
On a Thursday night (9 July 2009) at the Blarney Stone Irish Pub, Cain Aguiar had the misfortune of chatting to a young lady who was with a man named Foster Akoteu.  Foster was jealous that his lady friend was talking to Cain and decided to fight him. Outside the Blarney Stone, Foster and his friend Sioeli Seau set upon Cain, hitting him with bottles and trying to bring him down but Cain remained standing, defenceless to the attack.  Jacob, who was out with Foster and Seau and wanted to "help", ran up to Cain from the side and hit him in the face, which caused him to fall to the ground and smack his head hard against the curb with nothing to break his fall.  Foster then kicked and stomped on Cain's head and said, "Welcome to Australia, bitch".
Cain Aguiar
Cain suffered horrendous brain injuries and his family, who flew in from Canada, made the decision to turn off life support days later.


Cain's background
Cain was 25 years old when he was killed.  As a Canadian, he had come to Australia to begin a new life and had been in Australia for a month, living with relatives.  He was a qualified pilot and financial analyst and had come to Australia to pursue a new career.  He has left behind his parents, grandparents, sibilings and a nephew.


Jacob's background


Jacob Polutele
Jacob was 22 years old at the time of the attack and on a suspended sentence for causing serious injury in an unrelated case.  He is of Tongan origin and has four siblings.  Jacob left school part way through Year 11 and became involved in amphetamines and ecstasy, working as a labourer and in meat works.  Jacob's drinking began to interfere with his work and he spent six months unemployed before he attacked Cain.


Outcome of trial: Jacob pleaded not guilty to manslaughter but a jury found otherwise.


Sentence:  7 years before eligible for parole (10 years max).  This was the same sentence as the one handed down to Foster.


You can read the judgement here or listen to it here.  Media coverage is available here and here.

Senseless Pakenham Attack

Crime: Manslaughter
Occurred: 8 November 2010
Sentenced: 15 August 2011
Where:  Outside Pakenham McDonalds (Princes Highway, Pakenham)
Convicted: RPJ (unidentified minor)
Victim: Cameron Lowe



What happened?
On 6 November around 12am on a Saturday night, Cameron, his two brothers and some friends went to Hungry Jacks, before walking over to McDonalds nearby.  They were denied service at McDonalds because they went through the drive-through on foot.
RPJ was on a party bus which stopped off at McDonalds.  He had consumed 15 Pulse vodka energy drinks.  As he got off the bus he said he wanted a fight, and his mates told him not to be silly.  Nevertheless, he encountered Cameron's group outside McDonalds and there was a bit of back and forth.  Cameron commented sarcastically that he was a drug dealer and asked RPJ not to speak to him.  RPJ then punched Cameron in the side of his jaw and knocked him unconscious.
Cameron was assisted by his brothers and went home.  The next morning no one was able to wake him.  He was taken to hospital but on 8 November had life support switched off due to no signs of brain activity.


Cameron's background
Cameron was 17 years old when he died.  He was a former student of Drouin Secondary College.  After his death his parents donated his organs, which have gone on to save the lives of others.  His family have been devastated by his loss.  A Facebook tribute page was set up to honour Cameron's death, which subsequently attracted negative and hurtful comments by trolls.


RPJ's background
RPJ was 17 years old at the time of the attack.  He left school in Year 8 and completed an apprenticeship as a floor tiler.  He has had no previous convictions.  A week before killing Cameron, he attended a party where he saw someone he didn't like and announced "I want to hit that kid with the red hair" and later punched the red-haired boy unconscious.


Outcome of trial: There was no trial because RPJ pleaded guilty.


Sentence:  Six and a half years imprisonment (nine years max), having served two days already in custody.


You can read the judgment here and media coverage here and here.

Monday, August 22, 2011

Backstabbing in Hastings

Crime: Manslaughter
Occurred: 8 July 2009
Sentenced: 10 August 2011
Where: 1 Mullett Street, Hastings
Convicted:  Kenny Bourbaud
Victim:  Willy Tiotala

What happened?
Willy lived in the flat above Kenny.  In the afternoon of 8 July 2009, Willy came downstairs to Kenny's for a few drinks. Some time later, there was friction and Kenny asked him to leave.  Later in the evening, Kenny called Willy to come downstairs and fight him.  Willy got out of bed and went downstairs for a fight.  Kenny's parents had come over to visit and they joined in the fight - so did Scott Smith, one of Kenny's mates.
While his family and friend continued to fight Willy, Kenny went into the house and came back with knife with a 20cm blade.  He stabbed Willy in the back, breaking some rib and piercing Willy's lung and liver in a wound that ran 19cm deep - nearly the whole length of the blade.  Willy died soon after.
Upon questioning from police, Kenny indicated that there was bad blood between him and Willy and that he wanted to teach Willy a lesson for how Willy had treated him in the past.

Willy's background
Willy had four children was with his partner, Kerry, for 14 years.  It was noted during sentencing that his death has had a profound effect on his family members.

Kenny's background
Kenny was 22 years old when he killed Willy.  He has two siblings and dropped out of school in Year 7.  From the age of 13 he has used substances including alcohol, speed and cannabis.  Kenny has a history of offences including assault with a weapon, threats to kill, burglary and failure to answer bail.  Kenny has been ordered to pay fines and serve community service in the past.  While in remand Kenny was caught with receiving drugs underneath a postage stamp on a letter.

Outcome of trial:  Kenny had two trials terminated before having his third and final trial carried out in 2011.  He plead guilty to manslaughter but not guilty to murder.  The jury agreed with Kenny and found accordingly.

Sentence: 6 years before eligible for parole (9 years max).  762 days of the sentence has already been served in remand.

You can read the judgment here and media coverage here.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Brothers Assassinate Bikie Gang Member

Crime: Murder and manslaughter
Occurred:  23 October 2008
Sentenced:  23 March 2011
Where: Bandidos' Clubhouse, Leather Street, Geelong
Convicted: John Bedson (murder) and Derek Bedson (manslaughter)
Victim:  Ross Brand


What happened?
On Geelong Cup Day (22 October), a fight broke out between a nominee of the Bandidos Motorcycle Club and a member of the Death Before Dishonour club (a youth group allied with the Rebels).  John Bedson and his half brother, Derek Bedson, wanted to avenge the Death Before Dishonour member who had been assaulted.  They drove out to the Bandidos' Geelong club house with a .22 semiautomatic rifle.  Ross Brand and several associates came outside to see what was going on.  John Bedson fired six times, one bullet hitting Ross Brand in the forehead and another striking his associate near the right butt cheek, exiting through his left thigh.  Ross suffered horrendous brain injuries and died in hospital in the early hours of the next morning.

Ross Brand


Victim's background
Ross was 51 when he died. As a fully fledged Bandidos member, he was a targeted enemy of the Rebels, who suspected him of firebombing their clubhouse in the past.  A year earlier they had ambushed his home but he wasn't there.  Before he was shot he reached down toward his trousers.  John claimed he was reaching for a gun or a knife which he was known to carry around, whereas the Crown claimed that Ross was merely about to tuck in his shirt or do up his fly.  Police have stated there were reliable reports that Ross had access to guns and grenades.  
He left behind his wife of 14 years and a 12 year old son. Among the flowers at the scene of his death was a note that read: "Dad, I really don't know what to write, I wish I didn't have to write anything, but here we are … we're all going to miss you so fucking much."




John Bedson as sketched in court.
John Bedson's background
John was 24 at the time of the killing.  He is the half brother of Derek.  During school he suffered from learning disabilities and left school after failing Year 10.  He began using ice, LSD and cannabis.  When he was 18 he formed the group Death Before Dishonour with some friends, and went on to become a full member of the Rebels. He has 17 prior convictions for incidents including kicking cars and brandishing a knife (both incidents occurred while intoxicated). He was living with his girlfriend and her nine year old son until the killing.  Under their influence he had stopped drinking.  He and his girlfriend were going to get married in December 2008, but he has been in remand since the killing.


Derek Bedson's background
Derek was 21 at the time of the killing.  He completed Year 12 VCAL at Belmont High School and afterwards traveled from Geelong to Melbourne to complete a carpentry apprenticeship.  He began using cannabis from the age of 12 and engaged in amphetamine use from the age of 18. He has had previous convictions for possessing a handgun without a license and drug possession.  Derek was not a member of any of the bikie gangs involved.

Outcome of trial: John offered to plead guilty to manslaughter but the prosecution pursued a murder indictment instead.  A jury trial was required and they found him guilty.  Derek pleaded guilty to manslaughter and no trial was needed.  The men were also convicted for causing injury to the man who was shot in the butt.

Sentence:
John: 18 years imprisonment before eligible for parole (23 years max), with over two years of the sentence already served in remand.
Derek: Eight years before eligible for parole (12 years max), with approximately a year and a half of the sentence already served in remand.

You can read the judgement here.  Media coverage is available here and here.

Several bikies attended the sentencing decision.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Non-Payment of $2000 Debt Costs Life

A heroin addict was killed during an argument over money owed.
Crime:  Manslaughter

Occurred:  13 June 2004

Sentenced: 4 February 2011

Where: Convicted's home - not identified (body found in Thomastown)

Convicted: Bassam Tiba

Victim: Richard Haddara


What happened?
Richard owed Bassam's brother, Zain, some money.  Richard accepted $2000 in exchange for supplying electrical equipment, but never provided the equipment or returned the money.


On Sunday 13 June 2004, at Bassam's residence, Bassam had an argument with Richard over the money and stabbed him once in the chest, which pierced his heart and killed him.  Bassam put Richard in the back of Richard's car and drove it over to Zain's house, who jumped in the car and urged Bassam to go to the hospital.  Bassam drove in that direction but decided to dump the car at a carpark in Thomastown instead. He travelled on foot to another brother's house (Mohammed) and the next day flew out of Australia with his family, using Mohammed's passport.  He was extradited from Honiara in the Solomon Islands in December 2008.

Victim's background
Richard was a heroin addict who met Bassam in prison.  Before his death he was avoiding Bassam and his brother and was either unwilling or unable to pay back the debt owing.


Convicted's background
Bassam was born in Lebanon and came to Australia at the age of 12 with his parents and seven siblings.  He left Preston Tech after completing Year 10.  In 2000 he was imprisoned for four years and six months (before eligible for parole), for savagely beating his wife with a hose and a metal tipped cane.  His wife stayed loyal and waited for him while he was in prison.  He was out on parole for a month when he stabbed Richard to death.  After the killing he fled to Lebanon and then Egypt, working as an English teacher with his wife.  When he is released from prison he wants to return to his wife and children who remain in Egypt.  Currently in restrictive custody, he has been confined to his cell for 18 hours a day since May 2010, following an incident in prison involving other members of the Haddara family.

Outcome of trial: Bassam was originally indicted for murder, but once the charge was changed to manslaughter he pleaded guilty so there was no need for a trial.

Sentence:  6 years and 6 months before eligible for parole (max 10 years).

You can read the judgement here.  This killing has taken place in the midst of family feuding in the northern and western suburbs (major players including the Haddaras, Bibas and Chaouks).  You can read about it here, here and here.  The death toll points to another major gang war currently playing out around us.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Three Year Old Killed in Lalor

A three year old boy died in the back of a car boot.
Crime:  Manslaughter
Occurred:  4 March 2010
Sentenced:  2 February 2011
Where: Lalor area
Convicted:  Gursewak Dhillon
Victim:  Gurshan Singh


What happened?
Gursewak and his family lived with another family at 28 David Street in Lalor.  At around 11.30am on a Thursday morning, he opened a door without realising that Gurshan Singh, a three year old son of the other family, was on the other side.  The door struck the boy in the head and knocked him unconscious.  Gursewak, who had outstanding immigration violations, was scared that he would get in serious trouble from migration authorities if the police or ambulance attended the house.  He put the boy in the boot of his car and drove around the area for two hours, in which time the Gurshan either suffered from fatal heatstroke (the boot would have reached temperatures over 40 degrees Celsius) or asphyxiated.  At one stage Gursewak drove past the Northern Hospital but did not stop in.  He eventually ran out of petrol and flagged down a lift to the petrol station from a motorist while the boy remained in the boot. At this stage he checked the boot to see that Gurshan was no longer alive.  He dumped the corpse in long grass at Oaklands Junction, near Melbourne Airport.  A truck driver discovered the body at 6:20 that same evening.  Meanwhile, Gursewak returned to David Street where he denied any knowledge of the boy's whereabouts until three days later.



Gurshan and his mother
Victim's background
When Gurshan was discovered missing, a statewide campaign was launched to look for the three year old child.  When he was struck by Gursewak his mother was in the shower and his father was at the local library.  
Since arriving in Australia two months beforehand, Gurshan was at times sick from the Melbourne heat.  On the day of his death he had not eaten anything.  His parents expressed their devastation through a victim impact statement which was considered in the judge's sentence.  They have returned home to India.



Convicted's background
Gursewak was 24 years old when he killed Gurshan.  He grew up in India and came to Australia on a student visa in 2006.  Gursewak did not complete his studies (which may have led to his immigration problems) and found work as a courier and taxi driver instead.  His wife and daughter lived with him in Melbourne for a time but are now in India.  


28 David Street Lalor where the initial incident occurred
Outcome of trial: Gursewark pleaded guilty before his committal hearing so a trial was not necessary.  He did not apply for bail while awaiting sentencing.




Sentence:   Three years before eligible for parole (five years max).  He has already served nearly one year of his sentence in remand.  Upon being freed he will be deported back to India.


You can read the judgement here.  Media coverage is available here and here.



Where the body was found