Take note

The content of this blog is based on publicly available information and is intended to convey a short summary of facts surrounding each Victorian murder and the sentence imposed. It is not pushing an agenda for harsher/more lenient sentencing practices in Victoria.
Showing posts with label murder. Show all posts
Showing posts with label murder. Show all posts

Friday, April 12, 2013

Ashwood Rooming House Rampage - Not Guilty

A man with a psychotic disorder lashed out after being evicted from a rooming house 

Charges: Murder and intentionally causing serious injury

Occurred: Friday, 15 March 2012

Where: 32 Salisbury Road, Ashwood

Judgment:  12 April 2013

Accused:  Barry Lee Kingi

Victims:  Jared Clinton (deceased), and Lisa, Jeremiah and Vincent Vu (injured)

What happened?
For several weeks, Barry, a 28 year old man who had been previously diagnosed with a psychotic disorder, had been living in an allegedly unregistered rooming house in Ashwood with, among others, Jared Clinton, Lisa Vu and her two children. On the night before the attack, Lisa, who ran the establishment, informed Barry that he would have to leave because of the damage he had earlier caused to an internet connection plug.  Barry grew angry and began to act unusually - he was seen later on that night lying on the floor muttering to himself.  In the early hours of the morning he knocked on all the residents' doors.  He came to Jared's door at 4am and a physical altercation ensued.  Barry dragged Jared out onto the street and attacked him further.  He left Jared lying helpless and returned inside the house.  Jared, 34 years old, died the next day in hospital of 'severe injuries to the head exacerbated by the injuries to his abdomen'.
Emergency crew at the scene (source).

Barry then entered the room occupied by Lisa and her two children.  He attacked all three of them, causing lacerations, bruising and memory loss to Lisa (who was in hospital for three days), head injuries to Jeremiah, a 15 year old boy who was hospitalised for two weeks, and several abrasions and bruises to Vincent, who was only three years old.

Later, during an interview with police, Barry (who was later observed by a forensic psychiatrist to be 'floridly psychotic and manic') did not say much other than that he was 'acting on a self defence theme'.

Outcome of trial
The prosecution and defence counsel agreed to run a hearing before a Judge pursuant to the Crimes (Mental Impairment and Unfitness to the Tried) Act 1997 (Vic).  Under that legislation, if it is established that the accused has a defence of mental impairment, he or she must be found not guilty.

The Judge was satisfied that Barry had a mental impairment which caused him to have no understanding of the nature and quality of his actions, nor that his conduct was wrong.  Accordingly, Barry was found not guilty of all charges.

Orders
Police outside the Ashwood home (source).
Barry received a custodial supervision order for a mandatory nominal term of 25 years. He was committed into the custody of Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, which runs the Thomas Embling Hospital, a 116 bed secure mental health facility in Fairfield that houses patients from the criminal justice system. Barry will spend a minimum of 25 years in custody before the Court reviews the order.  In the meantime he may apply for temporary leave or extended leave from custody, which will be granted only if it is considered that the public will not be put at risk by his presence.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Friday, April 5, 2013

Dandenong Man Killed for Caricature Depicting Woman as Fat

A 26 year old man was fatally stabbed in the chest in his new home.
Crime: Murder

Occurred: 15 July 2011

Where: 44 Princes Highway, Dandenong

Sentenced:  5 April 2013

Convicted: Boronika Gam Hothnyang

Victim: William Awu

What happened?
William and Boronika, both Sudanese, belonged to a group of friends who enjoyed drinking and socialising. Around mid-July 2011 Boronika allowed William to move in with her.

On 15 July, Boronika, William and three other friends, including her boyfriend, rose at 8:30am to continue a drinking binge that had started the day before. Throughout the day more people visited the house, some for a short time, some hanging around all day.

As Boronika drank, she also grew more aggressive and agitated. She was upset when her boyfriend taunted her that she came to Australia from Kenya rather than Egypt, and she left the house to pay a visit to the Dandenong branch of the Department of Human Services to complain about a door in her home that needed fixing.

When she returned home, William drew a caricature of Boronika that depicted her as being overweight. Her boyfriend laughed at the picture and teased her about it. Angry, Boronika told William to stop drawing pictures like that and that both men should stop the taunting or there would be consequences.

At around 2.15pm in the afternoon, after her boyfriend went back to bed, Boronika was witnessed by friends as putting her arm around William's neck so that he struggled to breath. Two friends made Boronika back off, and she continued drinking until 4pm when she announced she was going to bed.

Soon after, Boronika emerged from the bedroom, walked into the kitchen and grabbed a knife, holding it behind her back as she approached William, who was passed out in the corner of the room. She stabbed him once to the chest. He died of blood loss at the scene.
Boronika used a kitchen knife similar to this one to attack her friend (source).
Victim's background
Born in Sudan, William was the third child among ten children. He fled to Egypt in 2002 and moved to Australia with his family in 2004. He studied English for a brief period and later worked as a farm labourer in Victoria and New South Wales. He also had a talent for drawing caricatures. He was unemployed at the time of his death.

Soon after his arrival in Australia, he developed a drinking problem and fell in with the wrong crowd. At the time of his murder his blood alcohol reading was 0.42. Six weeks before he was killed, he was hospitalised for pulmonary tuberculosis and told to quit smoking and drinking.

All ten of William's siblings, as well as his mother, provided victim impact statements to the Court.

Convicted's background
Boronika was 24 years old at the time of the murder. She was one of six children, born in the Sudan. Her father was a factory worker and her mother was the primary caregiver. Boronika never attended school. Despite the civil war raging in her country, she reported to have a happy childhood, although she moved to Egypt when she was 13 years old, accompanied by an abusive brother and an aunt who the judge described as "cruel, sadistic and manipulative".

Life in Egypt was tough. She worked as a domestic servant and endured abuse. Around this time she had an older boyfriend who she fell pregnant to, but suffered a late miscarriage.

She came to Australia around the age of 15 or 16 and, similar to William, fell in with the wrong crowd and began drinking heavily. She fell pregnant again, and this time was allegedly forced to undergo an abortion by her aunty. She attempted suicide soon after. She fell pregnant again to the same boyfriend but he broke up with her.

She went on to have three children borne to three abusive fathers. She continued to drink throughout her pregnancies. All three children were placed into the custody of the Department of Human Services at some point in their early childhood, in relation to Boronika's alcoholism. One of the fathers was also suspected of sexually abusing one or more of her children.

Boronika was admitted into psychiatric units in hospitals on several different occasions in relation to suicide attempts and threats of harm to her children. Each incident was accompanied by heavy drinking. Each time she was hospitalised, away from the influence of alcohol she was able to make a recovery. However, upon being released she would relapse back into her former lifestyle.
44 Princes Highway, Boronika's home and where the murder occurred (source).
Outcome of trial: Boronika pleaded not guilty but a jury found otherwise.

Sentence: 10 years and 6 months before eligible for parole (14 years max), with over a year of her sentence already served while on remand.

Factors that were taken into account to reach this sentence were: Boronika's prospects for rehabilitation, her young age, the time she would spend away from her children, her lack of premeditation, lack of prior offending, her remorse (although she could not remember the offence she did demonstrate sadness at  having killed her friend), her age and what the Judge described as her 'horrific background and personal circumstances'.  Balanced against these elements were punishment, deterrence, the seriousness of the offence and denunciation. The Judge also commented in passing that: 'All of this is such a sad reflection on our society, that we have groups of seemingly dispossessed men and women who have been brought here as refugees, with little or nothing to do except drink their days away.'

This case was unsuccessfully appealed in 2014.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Fatal Beating in Brooklyn for Wife's Lover

A 34 year old man was beaten to death outside his own factory.
Crime: Murder

Occurred: Sunday, 30 October 2011

Where: 19 Industry Park Drive, Brooklyn

Sentenced: 5 April 2013

Convicted: Mark Budimir

Victim: Dino Moresco

What happened?
Jana, Mark's wife, ran a nursery in Footscray called "Garden Door".  She purchased garden ornaments from Dino, who ran a manufacturing business in Brooklyn.  Jana began a sexual affair with him the day after he, her, and Mark had gone out together to celebrate her birthday in August 2011.  At this stage, Mark was unaware of the relationship between his wife and her garden ornament supplier.

In September 2011, after months of Jana threatening to leave the marriage, she left for a weekend away with Dino, while Mark stayed at home with the kids. Following the weekend, Mark learned from a friend that she had attended a nightclub with Dino. He also suspected Dino had joined her in Sydney the following night. Upon her return, Mark discovered racy text messages on her phone, and he realised that Dino and Jana were more than business associates.

A few days later, Mark drove over to Dino's factory in Brooklyn and threatened that if Dino did not leave Jana alone, Mark would put him on the "front page of the newspapers".

From left to right: Mark, Jana and Dino in happier times (source).

Soon afterwards, Jana told Mark to leave the matrimonial home because the marriage was over. In response, Mark slapped Jana across the face several times and then locked her in the bedroom.  Police were called, and Jana later applied for an intervention order. Mark was also convicted for false imprisonment and assault in relation to the bedroom incident, for which he received a suspended sentence.

On Sunday, 30 October, Mark drove around to his wife's house to find her and Dino loading some of Mark's belongings into a truck. Outraged, he then drove to Dino's factory and was spotted wearing gloves and running about suspiciously to avoid detection. A witness phoned Dino to alert him that someone behaving oddly was at the factory.

Some time later, Dino arrived at his factory to investigate. Mark caught him by the jumper and wrestled with him on the ground. Mark was able to struggle free and stood up, picking Dino up in the air and then throwing him down on the ground, where he landed on his head. Blood came out of his mouth. Mark then stood on Dino's chest several times, before loading him into his own truck and driving out to an abandoned industrial site.

He fetched some petrol from his parent's house nearby and returned, shoving Dino head first into a wheelie bin and setting it on fire.

While Dino's corpse burned, Mark drove off to buy a kebab and did a quick drive by on the fire before zooming off to New South Wales. He rang his wife, abusing her for her disloyalty before telling her that he had gotten rid of Dino so that Jana could return to him.  He also reportedly rang police and told them that he would only turn himself in after taking a holiday to Northern Australia (where and Jana had once enjoyed a nice vacation). Police were able to trace his location from his mobile phone, and arrested him in Broken Hill.

Victim's background
Dino's cousin and mother attended Court (source).

Dino was 34 when he was killed.  He reportedly ran his manufacturing business very successfully and was planning to soon retire.

Jana said in her victim impact statement, "The crime ended my physical relationship with Dino, but the emotional relationship continues. I cannot stop loving Dino."

His parents visit his grave every day.

Convicted's background
Mark was almost 41 at the time of the murder.  He met Jana at age 19, his first serious girlfriend, and they were married in their early twenties.   They had four children, who are now aged from 8 to 15.

The judge commented that Mark had lived a "largely blameless and in many respects admirable life" as a husband, father and small business owner.

Mark had former convictions of burglary, criminal damage and theft dating back to 1996 (occurring in the context of recovering a debt), as well as the conviction noted above for false imprisonment and intentionally causing injury to Jana when she asked him to leave in September 2011.

Mark also suffers from hepatitis C.

Outcome of trial: Mark pleaded not guilty to murder, but a jury of his peers found otherwise.  The judge commented on Mark's "vehement attack" pursued in cross-examination against Jana during the trial, suggesting that Mark blamed Jana as the "cause of the evil" in relation to the murder.

Sentence: 16 years before eligible for parole (18 years max), with over a year and a half already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Mark escorted out of the Court following sentencing (source).

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Gas Bottle Dispute in Goroke - Pregnant Woman Murdered

A 35 year old woman died from a gunshot wound intended for her fiance.

Crime: Murder and reckless conduct endangering life

Occurred: Sunday, 12 February 2012

Where: Goroke

Sentenced:  27 March 2013

Convicted:  Michael Terrence Kelly

Victim: Julie-Anne Trenery-Rogers

What happened?
Michael had a friend who died of an epileptic seizure in January 2012.  Michael became angry when later in the same month his son informed him that he had seen a man named Peter Brown taking items from the deceased friend's house.

Michael rang the police and then drove to Peter's house in Goroke with the intention of "giving him the hiding of his life".  Peter wasn't home but Michael did notice a 45 kilogram gas bottle in the yard, which he believed was taken from his deceased friend's house.

A little later, on 11 February, at somebody else's house, an altercation occurred between Michael's wife, Michael's son and Peter Brown.  Peter yelled "I'm going to kill someone, it's going to be another Horsham incident" (referring to this murder that occurred the day before).

Michael's wife later reported the incident to Michael, who was incensed.  He rose the next morning and began drinking at 10am, continuing throughout the day.  At 8:30pm he grabbed his .22 rifle and set off for Peter's house.
Police attend at Peter Brown's property (source).

Upon arriving, he fired off a shot through the front window and then forced his way into the house through the locked back door.  As he entered, Peter ran down the hallway to the front door.  Between the two men stood Julie-Anne, Peter's fiance, who cried out, "Don't do it!"

"Shut up, slut," Michael said, before firing off another shot at Peter.  The bullet entered Julie-Anne's back and pierced her heart, killing her at the scene.

Meanwhile, Peter was hiding at the back of his property.  After an unsuccessful search, Michael fired one more shot into Peter's car before driving away.

Victim's background
Julie-Anne was 35 years old and 20 weeks pregnant when she died.  She had another five children, aged from 20 months up to 14 years.  She was engaged to marry Peter Brown.  Julie-Anne's mother and brother have since had to rearrange their lives in order to care for the five children.  One of Julie-Anne's sons wrote in his victim impact statement, "There is only one Mum in the world for a child".  One of her daughters also wrote "Everything I pictured with Mum I don't picture anymore and I struggle to see my future".
Julie-Anne (source).
Convicted's background
Michael was around the age of 47 years old at the time of Julie-Anne's murder.  He grew up in Adelaide and was gang raped in Canberra at age 15.  He left school in Year 10 and subsequently held a number of jobs in manual labour and as a tattooist.

He has a history of poor health, suffering from three heart attacks since the mid-1990s.  He also had sciatica since 1995 and around 1998 contracted a post-surgical infection following carpal tunnel surgery.  He has been on a disability pension since 1995.  He also describes himself as an alcoholic.

Michael Drummond (source).
His first marriage ended after his wife cheated on him with his brother.  In response, Michael set the family home on fire and was convicted for arson.  Since then, he remarried and has five children.

He also has prior convictions for offences relating to dishonesty and property damage.

Outcome of trial: Michael pleaded guilty so there was no need for a trial.

Although he did not intend on killing Julie-Anne, he was nevertheless charged with murder because in Victoria, a person who unintentionally kills another in the course of a violent crime is liable to be convicted of murder as if they had done so intentionally.  This is sometimes referred to as statutory murder.  Michael's lack of intent remained relevant, however, when determining the appropriate sentence.

Sentence: 16 years before eligible for parole (19 years maximum), with over a year already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Geelong Man Kicked to Death for Defecating on Floor

A 55 year old alcoholic was bashed to death in a Geelong hotel.

Crime:  Murder / manslaughter

Occurred:  Sunday, 2 October 2011

Where:  Sir Charles Hotham Hotel, Geelong

Convicted #1:  Bradley James Walters (murder)
Sentenced:  7 December 2012

Convicted #2: Brett Ross Drummond (manslaughter)
Sentenced: 13 March 2013

Victim: Edwin Singer

What happened?
Bradley, Brett and Edwin were residents at the Sir Charles Hotham Hotel in Geelong.  Bradley and Edwin were unemployed alcoholics.  Brett worked in a local factory and also drank heavily.

Bradley and Brett were friends with the hotel cleaner, who had complained for some time about Edwin's habit of defecating in public areas of the hotel.  Over a number of incidents she discovered faeces on the carpet and sheets in his room, in the foyer, out on the street and in the bathroom.  Hotel residents, including Bradley and Brett, were growing increasingly upset at this behaviour.

On the Saturday before his death, a large smear of faeces appeared on the hallway carpet outside the bathroom door.  A trail of footsteps led back to Edwin's room.

Bradley confronted Edwin and told him he had a day to clean up the mess, but Edwin denied responsibility.

On Sunday, Bradley drank five to six litres of cask wine before intercepting Edwin on his way to the bathroom.  Bradley punched Edwin until he was on the floor and then kicked him repeatedly with his steel capped boots.

Bradley returned to his drinking while Edwin crawled back to his bedroom.  At various points in the evening Bradley returned to continue his assault on Edwin, at one stage accompanied by Brett, who also joined in the beating and who had consumed at least ten beers.

Later in the evening, the men dragged Edwin out to the fire escape.  He was either dead at the time or died soon after while he was at this location.  The men later dumped Edwin's corpse in a driveway neighbouring the hotel.

Victims' background
Edwin Singer (source)
Edwin, who was 55 years old at the time of his death and suffering from emphysema, died from blunt force trauma and sustained a number of injuries including a fractured nose, sternum and 27 rib fractures.  He is survived by a sister, a daughter and a step daughter.  His daughter, who was already suffering depression before his death, has deteriorated in mental condition since he was killed and now requires significant care from her step sister.  He was 55 years old when he died.  A year before his death he had participated in a newspaper interview and told journalists that he was a former social worker and had worked at Deakin University, but it is not clear whether this was true.

Convicted #1's background
Bradley was 45 years old at the time of the attack.  Born in Geelong, the middle child of five children and the son of a truck driver and a canteen worker, he did not enjoy a good relationship with his father and began drinking on a daily basis by the age of 17.  He left school at the end of Year 11.  At 22 he left home and fell in and out of employment, ending up mostly working in fruit picking, a lifestyle that enabled him to continue to drink heavily.
By the age of 27 Bradley had two children to another alcoholic, Pauline.  The couple were unable to look after their children and when the kids were aged 5 and 7 they were placed into the welfare system and Bradley has not seen them for over 12 years.
The Sir Charles Hotham Hotel (source)
A psychologist who interviewed Bradley for his trial observed that Bradley 'seems to be of the view that alcohol is the only thing that can give his life even the most fleeting sense of meaning'.

Convicted #2's background
Brett was approximately 44 years old at the time of the murder.  Born in Geelong, he was the middle child among six siblings.  His mother and father were both alcoholics and Brett suffered sexual abuse at the hands of two uncles.  By the time he was six years old, all of the children in the family had been placed into alternative care.  Brett spent the rest of his childhood in and out of boys' homes.  He began drinking at 14.  He left school after Year 10 and worked as a factory hand and woodcutter.  A psychologist described that at the time of sentencing Brett was "bordering on frank alcoholism".

Brett has a low IQ.  He has a prior criminal history that includes three assaults, dishonesty and driving offences, and a period of imprisonment.  At the time of the manslaughter he was on a suspended sentence for driving offences.

Outcome of trial
#1:  Bradley confessed what he did to police and was willing to plead guilty to manslaughter, but due to a number of factors (including that he continued to return to Edwin for more beatings throughout the night of the murder, indicating deliberateness), the prosecution pursued a murder charge and the matter proceeded to trial, where Bradley was found guilty by a jury of his peers.

#2:  Similarly, the prosecution pursued a charge of murder against Brett but changed its mind shortly before the sentence was handed down.  Brett pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter, and no trial was necessary.

Sentence
Bradley was sentenced to 17 years imprisonment before eligible before parole, 20 years maximum.  The judge recognised that Bradley had already served well over a year of his sentence whilst on remand.

You can read more about the crime here and here and the judgement for Bradley here and for Brett here.
The crime scene near where the body was found (source)


Thursday, February 28, 2013

69 Year Old Vigilante Stormed Hidden Valley

A 62 year old man was tracked down in the White Pages and murdered.

Crime: Murder

Occurred: 23 November 2011

Where: Hidden Valley

Sentenced:  28 February 2013

Convicted:  Clarence Stanley Nelson

Victim:  Graeme Benney

What happened?
Clarence and Graeme were acquainted through their wives, who were first cousins.  The two families spent a lot of time together while their children were young.  It was common for the kids to sleep in one room when the families were socialising.  However, the friendship drifted apart when Graeme and his wife separated in 1989.

In 2000, Clarence's children, now adults, reported among themselves instances of molestation at the hands of Graeme Benney and also Clarence's brother, Gregory Nelson.  No one went to the police regarding these allegations.

However, word did get to Clarence, and it appears he experienced some anger and held a grudge, for 11 years later he met an acquaintance at a shopping centre and produced a bullet from his pocket, describing it as intended for his brother.

In November 2011, following an instance where Clarence licked the inside of his 5 year old granddaughter's ear, one of Clarence's daughters alleged that Clarence had molested her until she was 15 years old.  Following a confrontation outside his son's home, Clarence's son told him "I know what you did...I'm going to bring your world undone.  You're fucked."

Clarence was unable to contact his daughter who made the accusations.  Instead, he walked into the garage and emerged with a 9mm semi-automatic pisto and ammunition.  The first target was his brother, but Clarence was unable to track down Gregory through the White Pages and family enquiries.

Clarence then turned to tracking down Graeme.  He drove to Graeme's address, arriving at roughly 8:15pm, whereupon he went inside and had a superficial, pleasant conversation with both Graeme and his wife.  Clarence then asked Graeme to join him outside to inspect some panel damage on his car.  Once outside, Clarence reached into his car, pulled out the gun and shot Graeme three times, saying "This will teach you, you bastard, for everything you've done" while Grame's wife stood nearby.

Graeme died of blood loss and internal organ trauma.  He suffered wounds in the heart, lung, stomach, bowel and kidney.

Later that evening, Clarence turned himself in at the Epping Police Station.

Victim's background
Graeme was 62 when he died.  He remarried in 1993 and lived in Hidden Valley with his family.  He leaves behind a widow, children and grandchildren.
A 9mm semi-automatic similar to the model used by Clarence (source).

Convicted's background
Clarence was 69 at the time of the murder.  He was born the eldest of eight children.  His father was a World War II veteran, who returned home to Australia injured and alcoholic.  Clarence grew up suffering physical abuse at the hands of his father and was also molested between the ages of nine and 12 by his father's friend.  He was pressured into a sexual relationship with his mother's best friend when he was 14.

Clarence finished Year 10 at a technical school and became a fitter and turner.  Successful in his career, he was an engineering manager at Carlton and United Breweries until he needed quadruple bypass surgery in 1990.

Clarence was a well-regarded member of his local parish and cared for his wife who suffered from a mental illness.  He had no prior convictions before the murder.

When first imprisoned, he attempted suicide.  He continues to suffer health issues today.  In sentencing, the judge remarked that he may die in prison.

Outcome of trial: Clarence pleaded guilty and no trial was necessary.

Sentence: 12 years before eligible for parole, 18 years maximum.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here and here.
Hidden Valley (source).

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Dromana Woman Died in Post-Coital Attack

A 54 year old woman was beaten to death after sex.

Crime:  Murder

Occurred:  26 April 2011

Where: Unknown address, Dromona

Sentenced:  19 February 2013

Convicted:  Dwaine Anthony Grant

Victim:  Julie Simmonds

What happened?
Despite the 22 year age gap between the couple, Dwaine and Julie had a sexual relationship dating back to Dwaine's early teens.  Over the last year, since Dwaine had moved to Dromona, the two were regular drinking buddies.  On the day of the murder, they drank cask wine and smoked pot together.  Later in the day, they had sex and then something, it is not clear what, made Dwaine snap.  He called Julie a "fuckwit" and a "gutter slut" and proceeded to beat her viciously, beginning in the living room and then moving into the bedroom, choking her to the point of crushing her larynx, ripping chunks of hair right off her scalp and battering her all over, including around her genitals and anus. He held her by the hair while punching her and finished off by repeatedly hitting her over the back of the head with a lump of wood. Julie died of "multiple injuries including neck compression" and was alive for the entire beating.

Victim's background
Julie, aged 54 at the time of her death, was an alcoholic.  She left behind three children and an ex-husband.  In sentencing, the judge commented that Julie's family were left with "a cruel and unjustified feeling that they did not protect her adequately in the vulnerable state which it was plain her alcoholism created".
The Dromana pier (source).

Convicted's background
Dwaine was 22 years old when he murdered Julie.  His father died before he was born and his mother found an undesirable de facto partner.  Dwaine experienced sexual abuse, witnessed ongoing domestic violence, and spent his earlier years in foster homes. Early on, Dwaine began racking up a series of offences in the Children's Court, related to dishonesty and motor vehicle offences.  He moved to Melbourne as a young adult and obtained a series of partial trade qualifications before he was sacked for his alcoholism.  In 2010 he moved back to Dromana where he spent his days drinking and lived on welfare.  As well as alcohol, Dwaine was a cannabis and (alleged) amphetamine user.
Dwaine also held a number of convictions in the Magistrates Court, none of them related to violence.
Dwaine and Julie drank cask wine on the day of the murder (source).

Outcome of trial:  Dwaine pleaded guilty so there was no need for a trial.

Sentence:  16 years before eligible for parole, 20 years maximum.

You can access the judgment here.  Media articles are available here and here.


Friday, February 8, 2013

Refugee Strangled to Death by Husband in Hampton Park

A 33 year old woman was murdered in front of her two children.
Crime: Murder

Occurred:  20 November 2007

Where:  41 Michelle Drive, Hampton Park

Sentenced: 8 February 2013

Convicted:  Soltan Ahmad Azizi

Victim:  Marzieh Rahimi

What happened?
Sometime after 1pm on Tuesday, a neighbour heard a baby crying followed by a man and woman arguing and then a woman trying to scream.
Inside the house, the fight between Soltan and Marzieh escalated.  Soltan punched Marzieh several times in the head and face and strangled her to death with her scarf.  He rang police at 2:23pm to report what he had done.

The couple's marriage
Soltan and Marzieh were cousins who entered into an arranged marriage in Afghanistan when Marzieh was 19 years old and Soltan 29.  According to Marzieh's sister, Marzieh reported domestic violence from the very first night of the marriage.

The couple had two children during their four years in Afghanistan.  Their eldest daughter was killed by gunfire when she was three years old.

The couple and their remaining child fled to Iran as refugees and lived in the alleyways of Tehran, while Marzieh had two more children and Soltan worked as a cobbler and teaboy.  They came to Australia as refugees in 2005 and had another two sons, settling in Hampton Park in 2007.

The family home at 41 Michelle Drive, Hampton Park (source).
In the months leading up to the murder, the relationship between Soltan and Marzieh became hostile.  Marzieh was contemplating leaving Soltan, and had reported instances of domestic abuse to her sister (who was now residing in the USA) and social workers.  She was afraid of Soltan.  One conflict a few weeks before her death saw Marzieh locking herself in the bathroom with her two youngest children for a number of days.  On two occasions during this period she rang 000 for assistance but, unfortunately due to language difficulties, no assistance was provided.

One week before Marzieh's death, Soltan rang up Marzieh's sister and told her that Marzieh had changed religion, had become too Australian and was intending to divorce him.  Marzieh's sister then counselled Marzieh over the phone to reconcile with her husband, but Marzieh stated that she was going to leave Soltan and there were a number of organisations who could provide the support to do so.


Victim's background
Marzieh was only 33 years old when she was killed.  She has left behind five children who now under foster care.  Victim impact statements were also provided by Marzieh's mother and sister.

Marzieh suffered severe panic attacks and a social worker who spent some time with Marzieh suspected that she suffered from post traumatic stress disorder following her horrific experiences in Afghanistan.

Soltan Azizi in court (source).
Convicted's background
Soltan was 43 years old when he killed his wife. Born and raised in Afghanistan, he completed high school and studied economics at Kabul University for four years before dropping out to join the police force.

After the Afghanistan government fell in 1992, he and his family became the subjects of targeted violence. His mother and sister were killed in a house bombing, and his brother was captured and tortured by the Taliban. In 1998, Soltan and Marzieh's family home was attacked by gunmen and their eldest daughter was shot to death.

Upon moving to Australia, Soltan studied English at tafe but did not work.

Soltan had no prior convictions.
 
Outcome of trial:  Although Soltan admitted to police at the scene that he killed his wife, he pleaded not guilty to her murder and underwent a trial where he was found guilty and sentenced in 2010.  However, this verdict was set aside by the Court of Appeal who found that evidence of his abuse against Marzieh at his trial was inadmissible.  Accordingly, the Department of Public Prosecutions pursued a retrial, where Soltan again pleaded not guilty but a jury verdict found otherwise.

Sentence:  16 years minimum before eligible for parole, 20 years maximum.  The judge recognised that over 5 years of his sentence had already been served.

You can read the judgment here.  Media articles are here, here, and here.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Brutal Assault in Swan Hill

 A 65 year old man was beaten to death in his own home.
Crime: Murder and theft

Occurred: 28 September 2011


Where: Harrisen Crescent, Swan Hill

Sentenced: 6 February 2013

Convicted: Darren Williams

Victim: Gary John Beggs

What happened?
Darren and Gary became acquainted in Bendigo when Darren asked Gary for a lift to Swan Hill for $20.  Gary obliged.  Six days later, over a cask of wine with his friend Kim (who happened to live on the same street as Gary), Kim told Darren that Gary was gay and was involved in a dispute with Kim over some money that she owed him.
Darren was disturbed at hearing this news, and as more people came to the premises that day for a party, he was heard by witnesses to make threats that he was "going to do the old fella over".
The party finished up at midnight but Darren stayed up and continued drinking.  Eventually, he grabbed a knife from the kitchen and walked down the road to Gary's house.
Shortly before the attack, Darren became convinced that Gary had sexually assaulted him.
Gary was in his lounge room when Darren stabbed him in such a frenzy around the chest and face that the knife broke off after becoming stuck in Gary's right eye.  Darren also dropped a stone statue on Gary's head, fracturing his skull.
Gary died of head and chest injuries.
Following the murder, Darren stole Gary's Toyota station wagon and dumped it in Dareton, New South Wales.

Victim's background
Gary was 65 years old when he was killed.  He is survived by his intellectually disabled 11 year old son, Nathan.  Nathan's mother left the family when he was three years old, and he was raised by Gary until he was 8 and then placed into the care of the Department of Human Services.  Nathan looked forward to his father's visits, and since his father's death has regressed.
Gary also left behind a brother in Austria.

Convicted's background
Darren was 37 years old at the time of the murder.  He was one of nine kids.  Darren was sexually abused as a child.  He told police that Gary had also sexually assaulted him, though he was unable to convince the sentencing judge on a balance of probabilities that this was the case.
Darren's mother died of cancer when he was 11, and his father died of diabetes-related complications when Gary was 35.  Gary was of Aboriginal, Afghani and Irish origin and identified as Aboriginal.  He spent most of his life at the Manatjira Mission in Dareton, New South Wales.
Darren dropped out of school around year 10, and worked seasonally in number of jobs including woodcutting and fruit picking.  He became an alcoholic by the time he was 18, and continued to abuse alcohol up until the murder.  Throughout the years he incurred a string of violent convictions dating back to when he was 21, spending over 5 (non-consecutive) years in prison.
He has a daughter who lives with her mother.

Outcome of trial:  Although Darren initially pleaded not guilty to the murder, he changed his plea to guilty and there was no need for a trial.

Sentence:  Darren was sentenced to 14.5 years imprisonment before eligible for parole, 17.5 years maximum. Darren served 494 days of his sentence while in remand.

You can read the judgment here, and media articles here and here.
The township of Swan Hill (source)

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Seven Time Killer Sought Minimum Term


This case is a little different to the general tenor of cases that are posted on this blog.  These murders occurred decades ago and Paul Steven Haigh (described as "Victoria's worst serial killer") was sentenced in 1980 and again in 1986.  He received life sentences for all murders committed and at the time, a minimum term could not be fixed.  The practical effect of a life sentence without a minimum term is that a prisoner will never be released.
The judgment summarised in this blog entry determined whether or not Paul Steven Haigh should be granted a minimum term to his sentence, to permit the possibility that one day he will be allowed back into society.


Crime:  Murder x 6
Occurred:  1978 - 1991
Where:  Windsor, Caulfield, St Kilda, Ripponlea, Olinda and Pentridge Prison
Sentenced:  Early 1980s
Convicted:  Paul Steven Haigh
Victims: Wayne Keith Smith, Sheryle Ann Gardner, Danny William Mitchell, Lisa Maude Brearley, Evelyn Abraham, Bruno Cingolani and Donald Hatherley.

What happened?
Paul shot Bruno Cingolani in the abdomen during an armed robbery at a pizza shop in Caulfield South.  Bruno later died in hospital.
Paul shot Evelyn Abraham in the head at an armed robbery of a Tatslotto agency in Windsor.  She died at the scene.
Paul's other murders took place in a broader killing spree by a lethal trio of men that lasted 11 months.
His mates, convicted killer Peter Wright and convicted killer and prison escapee Barry Quinn, were embroiled in a jealous circle.  Whilst on the run, Barry Quinn's girlfriend was murdered at Missipppi Lake.  Barry later confessed to the murder but police were suspicious it was actually committed by Sheryl Ann Gardner, a former lover of Quinn's who shared some animosity towards the murdered woman.
Paul's third victim was St Kilda man, Wayne Keith Smith, who had let Barry stay with him for a few days after he had fled prison.  Paul and an associate shot Wayne dead - the motive is unclear but it seems he was a former criminal associate and murdered in order to cover up the trio's crimes.

Two of Paul's victims: his 19 year old girlfriend, Lisa Bearley, and former associate Wayne Smith (source)
Paul then murdered Sheryl Ann Gardner by shooting her in her car at Ripponlea.  Also present was her nine year old son, Danny William Mitchell, who Paul pretended to console before shooting from behind once his head was turned.  It also appears they were murdered because Sheryl "knew too much".

Paul around the time he was first convicted (source)
During his hearing to have a minimum term imposed, Paul handed up a book to the judge entitled "The House of Blue Light", a series of letters that documented his murders.  Paul wrote of his sixth victim, his 19 year old girlfriend Lisa Maude Brearley:
I invited my girlfriend to a non-existent party, and she, accepting the invitation, went to the bush with my co-offenders and I.  However, the only thing that awaited her up the dark forest track was rape and Death.

He took her out to a secluded area in Olinda and later described the murder as follows:
I hadn't known my girlfriend for long, but I experienced her as a kind-hearted and nice enough lass. Unfortunately for her, because there wasn't a gun to shoot her with, a knife was used to take her life. This being the case, when the fellow who wanted sex with her had finished using her body to that end, I attacked her with the blade. Amazingly, it seems I stabbed her one hundred and fifty-seven times.

I hadn't stabbed anyone to death before, and she didn't, as you might see in a movie, die after one blow with the knife.  She fought surprisingly hard, and this fazed me.  Because of this, when she was finally still, I decided to stab her more, in order to make sure she was dead.

The last murder committed by Paul was in 1991.  He assisted a prisoner to commit suicide by hanging.  A minimum term was set for this murder, the law in Victoria having changed by this time.

Convicted's background
Paul is now 55 years old and was 21 years old at the time of the first murder.  He was adopted at the age of three months and did not complete Year 9.  His parents were unable to control him and he appeared regularly in the Children's Court for, amongst other things, stealing, car theft, malicious damage, breaking and entering and various assaults.
A psychiatrist has said of Paul:
He admitted he might stuff up again if he was released.  He might even kill but only with a good reason.  Education and religion provided no answers but he had "learned to play the game" and "learned to manipulate people".
In 2010, Paul's father died and was rumoured to have left behind approximately $850,000, which was inherited by Paul.  Despite this, in the current hearing, he chose to represent himself.  He was permitted to leave prison in order to attend his father's funeral.

Although he is considered to present some symptoms of a person with borderline personality disorder, this has not been conclusively diagnosed.

Paul Haigh, today (source)

Outcome of hearing
Carefully weighing a number of considerations, the judge determined that no minimum term should be set down.

Sentence
Paul will remain behind bars for the rest of his life.
You can read more about the crimes here and here and the judgment here.