Take note

The content of this blog is based on publicly available information and is intended to convey a short summary of facts surrounding each Victorian murder and the sentence imposed. It is not pushing an agenda for harsher/more lenient sentencing practices in Victoria.
Showing posts with label motive unknown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label motive unknown. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Dromana Woman Died in Post-Coital Attack

A 54 year old woman was beaten to death after sex.

Crime:  Murder

Occurred:  26 April 2011

Where: Unknown address, Dromona

Sentenced:  19 February 2013

Convicted:  Dwaine Anthony Grant

Victim:  Julie Simmonds

What happened?
Despite the 22 year age gap between the couple, Dwaine and Julie had a sexual relationship dating back to Dwaine's early teens.  Over the last year, since Dwaine had moved to Dromona, the two were regular drinking buddies.  On the day of the murder, they drank cask wine and smoked pot together.  Later in the day, they had sex and then something, it is not clear what, made Dwaine snap.  He called Julie a "fuckwit" and a "gutter slut" and proceeded to beat her viciously, beginning in the living room and then moving into the bedroom, choking her to the point of crushing her larynx, ripping chunks of hair right off her scalp and battering her all over, including around her genitals and anus. He held her by the hair while punching her and finished off by repeatedly hitting her over the back of the head with a lump of wood. Julie died of "multiple injuries including neck compression" and was alive for the entire beating.

Victim's background
Julie, aged 54 at the time of her death, was an alcoholic.  She left behind three children and an ex-husband.  In sentencing, the judge commented that Julie's family were left with "a cruel and unjustified feeling that they did not protect her adequately in the vulnerable state which it was plain her alcoholism created".
The Dromana pier (source).

Convicted's background
Dwaine was 22 years old when he murdered Julie.  His father died before he was born and his mother found an undesirable de facto partner.  Dwaine experienced sexual abuse, witnessed ongoing domestic violence, and spent his earlier years in foster homes. Early on, Dwaine began racking up a series of offences in the Children's Court, related to dishonesty and motor vehicle offences.  He moved to Melbourne as a young adult and obtained a series of partial trade qualifications before he was sacked for his alcoholism.  In 2010 he moved back to Dromana where he spent his days drinking and lived on welfare.  As well as alcohol, Dwaine was a cannabis and (alleged) amphetamine user.
Dwaine also held a number of convictions in the Magistrates Court, none of them related to violence.
Dwaine and Julie drank cask wine on the day of the murder (source).

Outcome of trial:  Dwaine pleaded guilty so there was no need for a trial.

Sentence:  16 years before eligible for parole, 20 years maximum.

You can access the judgment here.  Media articles are available here and here.


Thursday, December 13, 2012

Seven Time Killer Sought Minimum Term


This case is a little different to the general tenor of cases that are posted on this blog.  These murders occurred decades ago and Paul Steven Haigh (described as "Victoria's worst serial killer") was sentenced in 1980 and again in 1986.  He received life sentences for all murders committed and at the time, a minimum term could not be fixed.  The practical effect of a life sentence without a minimum term is that a prisoner will never be released.
The judgment summarised in this blog entry determined whether or not Paul Steven Haigh should be granted a minimum term to his sentence, to permit the possibility that one day he will be allowed back into society.


Crime:  Murder x 6
Occurred:  1978 - 1991
Where:  Windsor, Caulfield, St Kilda, Ripponlea, Olinda and Pentridge Prison
Sentenced:  Early 1980s
Convicted:  Paul Steven Haigh
Victims: Wayne Keith Smith, Sheryle Ann Gardner, Danny William Mitchell, Lisa Maude Brearley, Evelyn Abraham, Bruno Cingolani and Donald Hatherley.

What happened?
Paul shot Bruno Cingolani in the abdomen during an armed robbery at a pizza shop in Caulfield South.  Bruno later died in hospital.
Paul shot Evelyn Abraham in the head at an armed robbery of a Tatslotto agency in Windsor.  She died at the scene.
Paul's other murders took place in a broader killing spree by a lethal trio of men that lasted 11 months.
His mates, convicted killer Peter Wright and convicted killer and prison escapee Barry Quinn, were embroiled in a jealous circle.  Whilst on the run, Barry Quinn's girlfriend was murdered at Missipppi Lake.  Barry later confessed to the murder but police were suspicious it was actually committed by Sheryl Ann Gardner, a former lover of Quinn's who shared some animosity towards the murdered woman.
Paul's third victim was St Kilda man, Wayne Keith Smith, who had let Barry stay with him for a few days after he had fled prison.  Paul and an associate shot Wayne dead - the motive is unclear but it seems he was a former criminal associate and murdered in order to cover up the trio's crimes.

Two of Paul's victims: his 19 year old girlfriend, Lisa Bearley, and former associate Wayne Smith (source)
Paul then murdered Sheryl Ann Gardner by shooting her in her car at Ripponlea.  Also present was her nine year old son, Danny William Mitchell, who Paul pretended to console before shooting from behind once his head was turned.  It also appears they were murdered because Sheryl "knew too much".

Paul around the time he was first convicted (source)
During his hearing to have a minimum term imposed, Paul handed up a book to the judge entitled "The House of Blue Light", a series of letters that documented his murders.  Paul wrote of his sixth victim, his 19 year old girlfriend Lisa Maude Brearley:
I invited my girlfriend to a non-existent party, and she, accepting the invitation, went to the bush with my co-offenders and I.  However, the only thing that awaited her up the dark forest track was rape and Death.

He took her out to a secluded area in Olinda and later described the murder as follows:
I hadn't known my girlfriend for long, but I experienced her as a kind-hearted and nice enough lass. Unfortunately for her, because there wasn't a gun to shoot her with, a knife was used to take her life. This being the case, when the fellow who wanted sex with her had finished using her body to that end, I attacked her with the blade. Amazingly, it seems I stabbed her one hundred and fifty-seven times.

I hadn't stabbed anyone to death before, and she didn't, as you might see in a movie, die after one blow with the knife.  She fought surprisingly hard, and this fazed me.  Because of this, when she was finally still, I decided to stab her more, in order to make sure she was dead.

The last murder committed by Paul was in 1991.  He assisted a prisoner to commit suicide by hanging.  A minimum term was set for this murder, the law in Victoria having changed by this time.

Convicted's background
Paul is now 55 years old and was 21 years old at the time of the first murder.  He was adopted at the age of three months and did not complete Year 9.  His parents were unable to control him and he appeared regularly in the Children's Court for, amongst other things, stealing, car theft, malicious damage, breaking and entering and various assaults.
A psychiatrist has said of Paul:
He admitted he might stuff up again if he was released.  He might even kill but only with a good reason.  Education and religion provided no answers but he had "learned to play the game" and "learned to manipulate people".
In 2010, Paul's father died and was rumoured to have left behind approximately $850,000, which was inherited by Paul.  Despite this, in the current hearing, he chose to represent himself.  He was permitted to leave prison in order to attend his father's funeral.

Although he is considered to present some symptoms of a person with borderline personality disorder, this has not been conclusively diagnosed.

Paul Haigh, today (source)

Outcome of hearing
Carefully weighing a number of considerations, the judge determined that no minimum term should be set down.

Sentence
Paul will remain behind bars for the rest of his life.
You can read more about the crimes here and here and the judgment here.