Take note

The content of this blog is based on publicly available information and is intended to convey a short summary of facts surrounding each Victorian murder and the sentence imposed. It is not pushing an agenda for harsher/more lenient sentencing practices in Victoria.
Showing posts with label shooting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shooting. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Gas Bottle Dispute in Goroke - Pregnant Woman Murdered

A 35 year old woman died from a gunshot wound intended for her fiance.

Crime: Murder and reckless conduct endangering life

Occurred: Sunday, 12 February 2012

Where: Goroke

Sentenced:  27 March 2013

Convicted:  Michael Terrence Kelly

Victim: Julie-Anne Trenery-Rogers

What happened?
Michael had a friend who died of an epileptic seizure in January 2012.  Michael became angry when later in the same month his son informed him that he had seen a man named Peter Brown taking items from the deceased friend's house.

Michael rang the police and then drove to Peter's house in Goroke with the intention of "giving him the hiding of his life".  Peter wasn't home but Michael did notice a 45 kilogram gas bottle in the yard, which he believed was taken from his deceased friend's house.

A little later, on 11 February, at somebody else's house, an altercation occurred between Michael's wife, Michael's son and Peter Brown.  Peter yelled "I'm going to kill someone, it's going to be another Horsham incident" (referring to this murder that occurred the day before).

Michael's wife later reported the incident to Michael, who was incensed.  He rose the next morning and began drinking at 10am, continuing throughout the day.  At 8:30pm he grabbed his .22 rifle and set off for Peter's house.
Police attend at Peter Brown's property (source).

Upon arriving, he fired off a shot through the front window and then forced his way into the house through the locked back door.  As he entered, Peter ran down the hallway to the front door.  Between the two men stood Julie-Anne, Peter's fiance, who cried out, "Don't do it!"

"Shut up, slut," Michael said, before firing off another shot at Peter.  The bullet entered Julie-Anne's back and pierced her heart, killing her at the scene.

Meanwhile, Peter was hiding at the back of his property.  After an unsuccessful search, Michael fired one more shot into Peter's car before driving away.

Victim's background
Julie-Anne was 35 years old and 20 weeks pregnant when she died.  She had another five children, aged from 20 months up to 14 years.  She was engaged to marry Peter Brown.  Julie-Anne's mother and brother have since had to rearrange their lives in order to care for the five children.  One of Julie-Anne's sons wrote in his victim impact statement, "There is only one Mum in the world for a child".  One of her daughters also wrote "Everything I pictured with Mum I don't picture anymore and I struggle to see my future".
Julie-Anne (source).
Convicted's background
Michael was around the age of 47 years old at the time of Julie-Anne's murder.  He grew up in Adelaide and was gang raped in Canberra at age 15.  He left school in Year 10 and subsequently held a number of jobs in manual labour and as a tattooist.

He has a history of poor health, suffering from three heart attacks since the mid-1990s.  He also had sciatica since 1995 and around 1998 contracted a post-surgical infection following carpal tunnel surgery.  He has been on a disability pension since 1995.  He also describes himself as an alcoholic.

Michael Drummond (source).
His first marriage ended after his wife cheated on him with his brother.  In response, Michael set the family home on fire and was convicted for arson.  Since then, he remarried and has five children.

He also has prior convictions for offences relating to dishonesty and property damage.

Outcome of trial: Michael pleaded guilty so there was no need for a trial.

Although he did not intend on killing Julie-Anne, he was nevertheless charged with murder because in Victoria, a person who unintentionally kills another in the course of a violent crime is liable to be convicted of murder as if they had done so intentionally.  This is sometimes referred to as statutory murder.  Michael's lack of intent remained relevant, however, when determining the appropriate sentence.

Sentence: 16 years before eligible for parole (19 years maximum), with over a year already served while on remand.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

69 Year Old Vigilante Stormed Hidden Valley

A 62 year old man was tracked down in the White Pages and murdered.

Crime: Murder

Occurred: 23 November 2011

Where: Hidden Valley

Sentenced:  28 February 2013

Convicted:  Clarence Stanley Nelson

Victim:  Graeme Benney

What happened?
Clarence and Graeme were acquainted through their wives, who were first cousins.  The two families spent a lot of time together while their children were young.  It was common for the kids to sleep in one room when the families were socialising.  However, the friendship drifted apart when Graeme and his wife separated in 1989.

In 2000, Clarence's children, now adults, reported among themselves instances of molestation at the hands of Graeme Benney and also Clarence's brother, Gregory Nelson.  No one went to the police regarding these allegations.

However, word did get to Clarence, and it appears he experienced some anger and held a grudge, for 11 years later he met an acquaintance at a shopping centre and produced a bullet from his pocket, describing it as intended for his brother.

In November 2011, following an instance where Clarence licked the inside of his 5 year old granddaughter's ear, one of Clarence's daughters alleged that Clarence had molested her until she was 15 years old.  Following a confrontation outside his son's home, Clarence's son told him "I know what you did...I'm going to bring your world undone.  You're fucked."

Clarence was unable to contact his daughter who made the accusations.  Instead, he walked into the garage and emerged with a 9mm semi-automatic pisto and ammunition.  The first target was his brother, but Clarence was unable to track down Gregory through the White Pages and family enquiries.

Clarence then turned to tracking down Graeme.  He drove to Graeme's address, arriving at roughly 8:15pm, whereupon he went inside and had a superficial, pleasant conversation with both Graeme and his wife.  Clarence then asked Graeme to join him outside to inspect some panel damage on his car.  Once outside, Clarence reached into his car, pulled out the gun and shot Graeme three times, saying "This will teach you, you bastard, for everything you've done" while Grame's wife stood nearby.

Graeme died of blood loss and internal organ trauma.  He suffered wounds in the heart, lung, stomach, bowel and kidney.

Later that evening, Clarence turned himself in at the Epping Police Station.

Victim's background
Graeme was 62 when he died.  He remarried in 1993 and lived in Hidden Valley with his family.  He leaves behind a widow, children and grandchildren.
A 9mm semi-automatic similar to the model used by Clarence (source).

Convicted's background
Clarence was 69 at the time of the murder.  He was born the eldest of eight children.  His father was a World War II veteran, who returned home to Australia injured and alcoholic.  Clarence grew up suffering physical abuse at the hands of his father and was also molested between the ages of nine and 12 by his father's friend.  He was pressured into a sexual relationship with his mother's best friend when he was 14.

Clarence finished Year 10 at a technical school and became a fitter and turner.  Successful in his career, he was an engineering manager at Carlton and United Breweries until he needed quadruple bypass surgery in 1990.

Clarence was a well-regarded member of his local parish and cared for his wife who suffered from a mental illness.  He had no prior convictions before the murder.

When first imprisoned, he attempted suicide.  He continues to suffer health issues today.  In sentencing, the judge remarked that he may die in prison.

Outcome of trial: Clarence pleaded guilty and no trial was necessary.

Sentence: 12 years before eligible for parole, 18 years maximum.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here and here.
Hidden Valley (source).

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Seven Time Killer Sought Minimum Term


This case is a little different to the general tenor of cases that are posted on this blog.  These murders occurred decades ago and Paul Steven Haigh (described as "Victoria's worst serial killer") was sentenced in 1980 and again in 1986.  He received life sentences for all murders committed and at the time, a minimum term could not be fixed.  The practical effect of a life sentence without a minimum term is that a prisoner will never be released.
The judgment summarised in this blog entry determined whether or not Paul Steven Haigh should be granted a minimum term to his sentence, to permit the possibility that one day he will be allowed back into society.


Crime:  Murder x 6
Occurred:  1978 - 1991
Where:  Windsor, Caulfield, St Kilda, Ripponlea, Olinda and Pentridge Prison
Sentenced:  Early 1980s
Convicted:  Paul Steven Haigh
Victims: Wayne Keith Smith, Sheryle Ann Gardner, Danny William Mitchell, Lisa Maude Brearley, Evelyn Abraham, Bruno Cingolani and Donald Hatherley.

What happened?
Paul shot Bruno Cingolani in the abdomen during an armed robbery at a pizza shop in Caulfield South.  Bruno later died in hospital.
Paul shot Evelyn Abraham in the head at an armed robbery of a Tatslotto agency in Windsor.  She died at the scene.
Paul's other murders took place in a broader killing spree by a lethal trio of men that lasted 11 months.
His mates, convicted killer Peter Wright and convicted killer and prison escapee Barry Quinn, were embroiled in a jealous circle.  Whilst on the run, Barry Quinn's girlfriend was murdered at Missipppi Lake.  Barry later confessed to the murder but police were suspicious it was actually committed by Sheryl Ann Gardner, a former lover of Quinn's who shared some animosity towards the murdered woman.
Paul's third victim was St Kilda man, Wayne Keith Smith, who had let Barry stay with him for a few days after he had fled prison.  Paul and an associate shot Wayne dead - the motive is unclear but it seems he was a former criminal associate and murdered in order to cover up the trio's crimes.

Two of Paul's victims: his 19 year old girlfriend, Lisa Bearley, and former associate Wayne Smith (source)
Paul then murdered Sheryl Ann Gardner by shooting her in her car at Ripponlea.  Also present was her nine year old son, Danny William Mitchell, who Paul pretended to console before shooting from behind once his head was turned.  It also appears they were murdered because Sheryl "knew too much".

Paul around the time he was first convicted (source)
During his hearing to have a minimum term imposed, Paul handed up a book to the judge entitled "The House of Blue Light", a series of letters that documented his murders.  Paul wrote of his sixth victim, his 19 year old girlfriend Lisa Maude Brearley:
I invited my girlfriend to a non-existent party, and she, accepting the invitation, went to the bush with my co-offenders and I.  However, the only thing that awaited her up the dark forest track was rape and Death.

He took her out to a secluded area in Olinda and later described the murder as follows:
I hadn't known my girlfriend for long, but I experienced her as a kind-hearted and nice enough lass. Unfortunately for her, because there wasn't a gun to shoot her with, a knife was used to take her life. This being the case, when the fellow who wanted sex with her had finished using her body to that end, I attacked her with the blade. Amazingly, it seems I stabbed her one hundred and fifty-seven times.

I hadn't stabbed anyone to death before, and she didn't, as you might see in a movie, die after one blow with the knife.  She fought surprisingly hard, and this fazed me.  Because of this, when she was finally still, I decided to stab her more, in order to make sure she was dead.

The last murder committed by Paul was in 1991.  He assisted a prisoner to commit suicide by hanging.  A minimum term was set for this murder, the law in Victoria having changed by this time.

Convicted's background
Paul is now 55 years old and was 21 years old at the time of the first murder.  He was adopted at the age of three months and did not complete Year 9.  His parents were unable to control him and he appeared regularly in the Children's Court for, amongst other things, stealing, car theft, malicious damage, breaking and entering and various assaults.
A psychiatrist has said of Paul:
He admitted he might stuff up again if he was released.  He might even kill but only with a good reason.  Education and religion provided no answers but he had "learned to play the game" and "learned to manipulate people".
In 2010, Paul's father died and was rumoured to have left behind approximately $850,000, which was inherited by Paul.  Despite this, in the current hearing, he chose to represent himself.  He was permitted to leave prison in order to attend his father's funeral.

Although he is considered to present some symptoms of a person with borderline personality disorder, this has not been conclusively diagnosed.

Paul Haigh, today (source)

Outcome of hearing
Carefully weighing a number of considerations, the judge determined that no minimum term should be set down.

Sentence
Paul will remain behind bars for the rest of his life.
You can read more about the crimes here and here and the judgment here.