Take note

The content of this blog is based on publicly available information and is intended to convey a short summary of facts surrounding each Victorian murder and the sentence imposed. It is not pushing an agenda for harsher/more lenient sentencing practices in Victoria.
Showing posts with label not guilty mental impairment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label not guilty mental impairment. Show all posts

Friday, April 12, 2013

Ashwood Rooming House Rampage - Not Guilty

A man with a psychotic disorder lashed out after being evicted from a rooming house 

Charges: Murder and intentionally causing serious injury

Occurred: Friday, 15 March 2012

Where: 32 Salisbury Road, Ashwood

Judgment:  12 April 2013

Accused:  Barry Lee Kingi

Victims:  Jared Clinton (deceased), and Lisa, Jeremiah and Vincent Vu (injured)

What happened?
For several weeks, Barry, a 28 year old man who had been previously diagnosed with a psychotic disorder, had been living in an allegedly unregistered rooming house in Ashwood with, among others, Jared Clinton, Lisa Vu and her two children. On the night before the attack, Lisa, who ran the establishment, informed Barry that he would have to leave because of the damage he had earlier caused to an internet connection plug.  Barry grew angry and began to act unusually - he was seen later on that night lying on the floor muttering to himself.  In the early hours of the morning he knocked on all the residents' doors.  He came to Jared's door at 4am and a physical altercation ensued.  Barry dragged Jared out onto the street and attacked him further.  He left Jared lying helpless and returned inside the house.  Jared, 34 years old, died the next day in hospital of 'severe injuries to the head exacerbated by the injuries to his abdomen'.
Emergency crew at the scene (source).

Barry then entered the room occupied by Lisa and her two children.  He attacked all three of them, causing lacerations, bruising and memory loss to Lisa (who was in hospital for three days), head injuries to Jeremiah, a 15 year old boy who was hospitalised for two weeks, and several abrasions and bruises to Vincent, who was only three years old.

Later, during an interview with police, Barry (who was later observed by a forensic psychiatrist to be 'floridly psychotic and manic') did not say much other than that he was 'acting on a self defence theme'.

Outcome of trial
The prosecution and defence counsel agreed to run a hearing before a Judge pursuant to the Crimes (Mental Impairment and Unfitness to the Tried) Act 1997 (Vic).  Under that legislation, if it is established that the accused has a defence of mental impairment, he or she must be found not guilty.

The Judge was satisfied that Barry had a mental impairment which caused him to have no understanding of the nature and quality of his actions, nor that his conduct was wrong.  Accordingly, Barry was found not guilty of all charges.

Orders
Police outside the Ashwood home (source).
Barry received a custodial supervision order for a mandatory nominal term of 25 years. He was committed into the custody of Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, which runs the Thomas Embling Hospital, a 116 bed secure mental health facility in Fairfield that houses patients from the criminal justice system. Barry will spend a minimum of 25 years in custody before the Court reviews the order.  In the meantime he may apply for temporary leave or extended leave from custody, which will be granted only if it is considered that the public will not be put at risk by his presence.

You can read the judgment here.  News articles are available here, here and here.

Friday, March 1, 2013

Doncaster Dad Stabbed Wife to Death - Not Guilty

A woman was killed by her psychotic partner in front of her 11 year old daughter.

Crime: Murder (not guilty)

Occurred: 8 August 2010

Where: Marilyn Street, Doncaster

Sentenced:  1 March 2013

Not convicted:  Sestilio Cavallari

Victim:  Susan Wood

What happened?
Sestilio and Susan had been in a de facto relationship since 1985.  They had an 11 year old daughter, Tegan.  In the days leading up to Susan's death, Sestilio was acting a little off.  On 6 August 2010, he stood up his wife for lunch and later they had an argument.  He also booked a ticket to Italy, telling the travel agent that he needed to go by 9 August because "something bad [was] going to happen".  When the travel agent later rang to tell him that his Italian passport was expired and he wouldn't be able to use it for travel, Sestilio said he was already aware that was the case.

Susan was so worried by her partner, who was not talking much sense, that she rang her father to express her concern.  She asked her dad and brother to come over, but Sestilio took the phone and said that it was not necessary.  After another argument, Sestilio left the house and later returned, eventually tearing up his plane ticket. "I'm not going, but something's going to happen," he said.

Later that night, upon her father's request, Tegan slept in his bed.  Throughout the night she heard him say, "They're gunna take me away, they're gunna lock me up and your mum will know what she's done to me."

The next morning, Tegan heard her parents arguing and then her mother started screaming.  She ran into the bedroom to see that Sestilio was attacking and scratching Susan, and there was blood in her hair.  Susan cried out for Tegan to call triple 0.  Sestilio dragged Susan by her hair into the kitchen.  By the time Tegan had called emergency services and returned to the kitchen, her mother had been stabbed 37 times.  She died of wounds inflicted to her neck.
The street where Sestilio and Susan lived (source).
Victim's background
Susan is reported to have been 52 years old when she died. She was an associate director of an investment group.  She worked full time while Sestilio was the primary carer of Tegan.

Sestilio's background
Sestilio was reported to be 56 years old at the time of the murder.  Medical experts at his hearing described that during the murder and afterwards, he was in a psychotic state.  However, no underlying disorder (ie schizophrenia) had been diagnosed at the time of the hearing.  One doctor noted Sestilio's wish to reconciliate with Susan's family, and that as Sestilio tries to maintain a relationship with his daughter in the future, he will be at increased risk of depression and a relapse into psychosis.

Before and during the hearing, Sestilio was a patient at the Thomas Embling Hospital.

The Thomas Embling Hospital in Fairfield (source).

Outcome of trial
In 2012 a jury found that Sestilio was unfit to stand trial.  A subsequent hearing occurred before a judge who, after considering the evidence of several medical professionals, determined that Sestilio was not guilty on the basis of mental impairment.

The judge noted that Susan's brother, Dr Graeme Wood, had been receiving "persistent" contact from the hospital where Sestilio was staying, which was "on the surface of it, appear[ed] to be extremely insensitive".  The judge further observed that the particular order imposed on Sestilio did not enable conditions, but recommended that hospital staff discuss the issue with Dr Wood.

Sentence: Sestilio was made liable to a custodial supervision order and committed into the custody of the Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health.  The nominal term of his order is 25 years beginning from 8 August 2010.

You can read the judgment here.  A news article is available here.  You can find more information about mental impairment and custodial supervision orders in the Victorian criminal justice system here.